top of page
Search

Why Engagement — Not Retention — Is the Real Workforce Risk

  • drcutts0
  • 38 minutes ago
  • 3 min read
And You Can Change This!
And You Can Change This!

📊 Today’s Workforce Reality

  • 31% of U.S. employees are engaged at work — Gallup

  • Quit rates have cooled to ~2% monthly, near pre-pandemic levels — U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

  • Highly engaged teams show 21% higher profitability and 17% higher productivity — Gallup


While the pandemic-driven Great Resignation pushed turnover to record highs, today’s labor market looks different. Fewer employees are leaving — not because engagement has improved, but because economic uncertainty is encouraging people to hold onto their jobs.

And that creates a quieter—but more expensive—risk: people stay, but many are not fully invested.


Retention measurements tell you who left. Engagement tells you how much performance you’re actually getting from the people who stayed.


Studies consistently show that teams with higher engagement deliver:

  • greater productivity

  • stronger financial performance

  • better customer satisfaction

  • lower absenteeism and internal friction


Conversely, when engagement is low, teams often struggle with:

  • minimal discretionary effort

  • slower execution

  • decreased innovation

  • managers constantly pushing instead of teams pulling


In the current environment, leaders must shift their focus from holding onto people to unlocking the discretionary effort of the people already there.


Why Traditional Approaches Miss the Real Issue

Most organizations still rely on annual engagement surveys.

But research suggests these tools often capture surface sentiment without revealing why employees feel disengaged. Leaders end up with scores instead of real insight. By the time results are analyzed and action plans built, the moment has already passed.


To understand engagement accurately, organizations need measurement that is:

  • more frequent

  • more granular

  • tied to real behaviors

  • paired with qualitative listening


Four Practical Moves Leaders Can Make Now

These are not perks or morale boosters — they are operational shifts that change how work actually gets done.


1. Replace annual surveys with real-time diagnostics

Use short pulse checks combined with team listening sessions to uncover what’s draining energy or blocking performance — and act on it quickly. Engagement is dynamic, and measurement should be too.


2. Shift managers from supervisors to performance coaches

Teams don’t disengage from companies — they disengage from managers. Equip managers to:

  • conduct frequent developmental conversations

  • remove performance obstacles

  • reinforce accountability through coaching

  • clarify performance expectations with empathy


Building these capabilities increases engagement because people feel seen, supported, and developed — not just monitored.


3. Give teams real ownership over work design

Not just inviting “feedback,” but delegating meaningful decision rights about how work is structured, sequenced, and delivered. When teams influence how the work happens rather than simply execute tasks, discretionary effort rises dramatically.


4. Engineer connection where hybrid work dilutes it

Connection doesn’t happen accidentally anymore. Structure routines that build alignment and trust:

  • purpose-driven start-of-week briefs

  • cross-team problem-solving forums

  • celebration of team wins

  • shared learning cycles


Intentional connection fosters cohesion and collective momentum, even in geographically distributed work.


The Bottom Line

In today’s labor market, retention — as measured by quitting and turnover — may be stable or even lower than during the pandemic. But stability doesn’t equal engagement.

Employees may stay because they want security.Organizations may push for higher output with fewer resources.Engagement drops. Performance follows.

Leaders who focus only on retention metrics will miss this hidden drag.

But leaders who understand the real work — how people feel, contribute, and grow — will unlock the potential already inside their teams. That’s what drives productivity, innovation, and sustainable success.


In fact, research shows that business units in the top engagement quartile deliver roughly 23% higher profitability than those in the bottom quartile — showing that engagement isn’t just a “feel-good” metric, it’s a competitive advantage.

Further Reading


Engagement Trends & Business Impact



Leadership & Meaningful Work



Measurement & Employee Experience



About the Author:

Dr. Nicole Cutts is an organizational consultant and executive coach specializing in leadership effectiveness, team performance, and employee engagement.

Connect on LinkedIn



 
 
 
bottom of page